Shifting the Balance

6 Ways to Bring the Science of Reading into the Balanced Literacy Classroom

These days, it seems that everyone has a strong opinion about how to teach young children to read. Some may brush off the current tension as nothing more than one more round of “the reading wars.” Others may avoid the clash altogether due to the uncivilized discourse that sometimes results. Certainly, sorting the signal from the noise is no easy task.

In this leading-edge book, authors Jan Burkins and Kari Yates address this tension as a critical opportunity to look closely at the research, reevaluate current practices, and embrace new possibilities for an even stronger enactment of balanced literacy.

You can create a quote by adding products to your cart and selecting Quote in checkout.

This title is also available through major book retailers, including Amazon.

Shipping Details
In stock. Free ground shipping. No minimum.


From phonological processing to brain research to orthographic mapping to self-teaching hypothesis, Shifting the Balance cuts through the rhetoric (and the sciencey science) to offer readers a practical guide to decision-making about beginning reading instruction. The authors honor the balanced literacy perspective while highlighting common practices to reconsider and revise—all through a lens of what’s best for the students sitting in front of us.
Across six shifts, each chapter

  • identifies a common instructional practice to reconsider
  • explores various misunderstandings that establish and keep that practice in play
  • shares scientific research to support its reconsideration
  • proposes an instructional shift to apply a new perspective, and
  • details several high-leverage instructional routines to support implementation of that shift.

By pinpointing gaps and overlaps—as well as common misunderstandings and missed opportunities between the competing lines of thought—Jan and Kari offer busy educators direction and clarification for integrating science and balance into their daily instruction, while keeping meaningful experiences with text a priority.

eBook Available Through Major Retailers

We offer ebook editions for most of our print titles so you can access on your computer, tablet, or e-reader from several major retailers including Amazon, Barnes and Noble, OverDrive, and View the full list of retailers here. For eBook purchases of 10+ please email us for a quote. Purchases of 20+ qualify for a bulk discount.

If you previously purchased an ebook from, they will remain available in your digital library. 

    About the Author(s)

    Dr. Jan Burkins was an elementary classroom teacher for seven years and a literacy coach for seven years. She has worked as a part-time assistant professor, a district literacy leader, and is currently a fulltime writer and consultant.


    Kari Yates is an author, speaker, consultant and staff developer with a passion for helping busy literacy educators thrive. Her experiences include classroom teacher, special education, Reading Recovery teacher, elementary principal and district literacy coordinator.


    Table of Contents

    Introduction: Embracing Science and Balance

    Shift 1: Rethinking How Reading Comprehension Begins

    • Clearing Up Some Confusion
    • Misunderstanding 1: Reading comprehension begins with print
    • Misunderstanding 2: Understanding spoken language and understanding written language are two different things
    • Misunderstanding 3: If children have strong oral language, they have most of what they need to learn to read
    • Misunderstanding 4: Successful comprehension in beginning reading texts means that reading comprehension is on track
    • A Short Summary of the Science
    • Recommendations for Making the Shift

    Shift 2: Recommitting to Phonemic Awareness Instruction

    • Clearing Up Some Confusion
    • Misunderstanding 1: Phonemic awareness develops naturally
    • Misunderstanding 2: Phonemic awareness and phonics are the same thing
    • Misunderstanding 3: Once children know all their letters and sounds, they will be able to read
    • Misunderstanding 4: Phonemic awareness is mostly a readiness or prereading skill
    • Misunderstanding 5: Intentional phonemic awareness instruction takes a lot of time or fancy resources
    • A Short Summary of the Science
    • Recommendations for Making the Shift

    Shift 3: Reimagining the Way We Teach Phonics

    • Clearing Up Some Confusion
    • Misunderstanding 1: Learning to recognize letters is just like learning to recognize any other object
    • Misunderstanding 2: Strengthening phonics instruction means purchasing a program
    • Misunderstanding 3: Phonics isn't really worth teaching because English is unpredictable and its spellings are unreliable
    • Misunderstanding 4: If you have a strong scope and sequence and solid instructional routines, you have systematic instruction
    • Misunderstanding 5: Learning phonics is boring
    • A Short Summary of the Science
    • Recommendations for Making the Shift

    Shift 4: Revising High-Frequency Word Instruction

    • Clearing Up Some Confusion
    • Misunderstanding 1: Sight words are the same as high-frequency words
    • Misunderstanding 2: High-frequency words can't be decoded
    • Misunderstanding 3: Children just need to memorize irregularly spelled high-frequency words as whole units
    • Misunderstanding 4: The best way to learn high-frequency words is to practice reading, writing, and/or chanting the letters over and over
    • Misunderstanding 5: If you can read a word, you know it
    • A Short Summary of the Science
    • Recommendations for Making the Shift

    Shift 5: Reinventing the Ways We Use MSV (3 Cueing Systems)

    • Clearing Up Some Confusion
    • Misunderstanding 1: We need to avoid telling students to "sound it out"
    • Misunderstanding 2: When they are problem solving, children should fist ask "What would make sense?"
    • Misunderstanding 3: Children don't need to use all of the print to read
    • Misunderstanding 4: The primary reason to teach children to decode is to problem solve the word in the moment
    • A Short Summary of the Science
    • Recommendations for Making the Shift

    Shift 6: Reconsidering Texts for Beginning Readers

    • Clearing Up Some Confusion
    • Misunderstanding 1: Decodable texts are loaded with problems
    • Misunderstanding 2: Predictable texts make learning to read easier
    • Misunderstanding 3: Using meaning as the go-to source of information will teach children to comprehend
    • Misunderstanding 4: As long as kids are spending time with books every day they will become better readers
    • A Short Summary of the Science
    • Recommendations for Making the Shift



    Product Details

    Grades: K, 1, 2
    Media: 200 pp/paper (est.)
    Year: 2021
    Item No: 1510Item No: 1557
    ISBN: 978-1-62531-510-6ISBN: 978-1-62531-557-1
    Publisher: Stenhouse PublishersPublisher: Stenhouse Publishers